Hello dear
Welcome To Steve & Cookie's By the Bay
At Steve & Cookie's By the Bay, nestled in Margate City, NJ, culinary passion meets a vibrant seaside atmosphere. This beloved eatery offers creative dishes that celebrate fresh, local ingredients, from their acclaimed fried oysters atop grilled romaine to sumptuous crab cakes paired with sweet potato fries. Diners rave about the warm hospitality and consistently excellent service, making every visit memorable. With a lively ambiance, often enhanced by live music, and weekly specials that entice food lovers, Steve & Cookie's is not just a meal; it’s an unforgettable dining experience that keeps patrons returning for more.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Oysters on the 1/2 Shell
Cauliflower Steak
Linguine and Local Clams
Jovial Penne [GF]
About
Steve & Cookie's By the Bay
Introducing Steve & Cookie's By the Bay: A Culinary Gem in Margate City
Nestled in the picturesque surroundings of Margate City, New Jersey, Steve & Cookie's By the Bay beckons food lovers with its warm ambiance and exceptional offerings. Located conveniently at 9700 Amherst Ave, this beloved establishment is not just a restaurant; it's a vital piece of the local dining experience.
Upon entering, guests are greeted by a vibrant atmosphere filled with the tantalizing aromas of fresh ingredients. The inviting dining room, often bustling with eager patrons, is a testament to the restaurant's popularity. As one satisfied guest shared, the “hype is real,” underscoring the restaurant’s ability to delight guests with every visit.
The menu boasts a selection of innovative and comforting dishes that embody a passion for quality. Start your meal with offerings like the Fried Oysters over Grilled Romaine adorned with roasted garlic aioli or indulge in the rich flavors of the Roasted Beets Salad featuring arugula, goat cheese, and toasted pistachios, all drizzled with a zesty lemon poppy seed vinaigrette. Prices range from $11 to $16, providing great value for the meticulous attention to detail.
For the main course, the Grain Fed 12oz Veal Chop Milanese and the Leidy's DoubleCut Stuffed 12oz Pork Chop are standout entrees that showcase culinary craftsmanship and local ingredients. Each dish is a harmonious blend of flavors, expertly crafted to ensure a memorable dining experience. Compliment your meal with an array of thoughtfully prepared sides, such as sauteed seasonal greens or roasted Brussels sprouts, each priced affordably at $7 to $10.
The joy at Steve & Cookie's doesn’t just end with the food. Reviews highlight attentive service that contributes significantly to the overall positive experience. Patrons express their delight not only in the culinary creations but also in the engaging atmosphere, often enhanced by live music that adds a lively touch to your dining experience.
The establishment also caters to those seeking a lighter fare or a quick snack with equally appealing happy hour specials. One happy customer recounted their love for the crab cake sandwich paired with sweet potato fries—“the best I can remember eating”—creating another reason to return.
In a world where dining options are plentiful, Steve & Cookie's By the Bay stands out as a beacon of excellence. The balance between price and quality makes every visit worth it, as echoed by loyal customers who continue to return for the same unbeatable experience they've cherished over the years. If you haven't yet dined here, you owe it to yourself to witness the culinary magic crafted by their talented kitchen, ensuring that every bite is a journey into flavor.
For reservations, contact them at +1 609-823-1163 and prepare to embark on a culinary adventure that truly celebrates food, community, and unforgettable moments.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Stunning dinner. The hype is real. Everything from the bread, wine, salads, entrees, service, dining room was top notch! We went a little off season (Nov) thinking it would be less crowded. It wasn't! The dining room was full by 6:30 and people waiting out the door to get in. Worth it, though. ”
“ Rarely have I been to a place where a line of happy people wait to get into eat, but this is the place. And, it's because of the food. Happy hour specials are great, people don't want to miss them! I had the crab cake sandwhich with sweet potato fries (the best I can remember eating). Everything that came out of the kitchen look wonderful. Service was great, too, especially the brave soul that opened the door and greeted all those hungry people personally as we entered! ”
“ Always a good time with amazing food and drinks over the top. They work with what you want and it’s an exciting environment. New stools are lovely and ladies- hangers under the bar! All in all - the BEST! Live music is lovely. ”
“ Absolutely incredible! Our favorite NJ dining experience. We've been coming here for years, and it never disappoints. The food, wine, and service are consistently top-notch, creating an unforgettable dining experience every time. The balance between price and value is just right, making it well worth every visit. We can't wait to return—it's always a pleasure!" ”
“ Got a reservation about two weeks prior for a Friday night in early March. The experience and food were fantastic as expected. Excited to come back for another dinner and to try out happy hour. ”
“ This place never misses. Every meal we have had here was incredible. It’s our go to celebration spot down the shore. Always check their specials because they have great deals and they are amazing. 5 star across the board every time ”
“ Loved it. First time here and it didn't disappoint. The food was excellent. Pricing is on the high side but you have to pay for quality. Looking to come back for Happy Hour. ”
“ The food is amazing. I want to curse that’s how good it is. The stuffed pork chop is the BEST thing I've ever eaten and I’m not exaggerating. I love this place. So much that I’d drive from queens to come here as often as I could. Bruce is a great bartender! Pictures below: Lolllichops and lobster Mac, stuffed pork chop, chocolate vodka martini and after dinner drink. ”